|
Freedom for Everyone
Adult day services benefit caregivers and clients, while creating a financial
opportunity for operators
By Wendi Hope King
Greg spent several years caring for his father who had Alzheimer's. He began
going to work later each day, calling from work throughout the day and leaving work early
in the afternoon, leading to pay loss and hostility within his workplace. Greg was also
spending less time with his family and refrained from social activities. He became
irritable and frustrated. His father needed more care than he was able to provide.
Finally, he decided he needed help. But where could he turn?
This is not an
uncommon scenario. According to Susana Perry, program manager of the National Adult Day
Services Association (NADSA), an association that promotes adult day services, programs
began in the 1940s in psychiatric hospitals, which sparked negative images in the public's
eye. Since then, adult day programs have undergone many changes that put them in a
positive light. Programs are in great demand and many communities are discovering they are
a prosperous business opportunity.
Some caregivers take a leave of absence, quit work or rearrange their schedules. Others
try to work and care for the person, which often leads to Greg's difficulties. Not
only are work patterns disturbed in these situations but private, social and financial
lives can experience turmoil as well. Adult day services relieve the caregiver from worry
by providing care for a loved one, whether it is for a weekend, a week, a day or a couple
of hours.
Adult day programs provide services for adults with dementias, cognitive impairments,
physical problems, behavioral problems and mental retardation. The age of accepted
patients begins at age 18 and continues into late adult life, unless the person is a
danger to himself or others, says Susan Rheem, executive director of Adult Care Services,
a day-program corporation in Prescott, Ariz. "We don't have a separate facility that
would allow us to continue that person's care," Rheem explains. "But people come
here for things such as incontinence or behavioral management, so we don't turn those
clients away."
The length of stay for clients varies greatly depending on the use of the program.
"Most clients are here for a long-term stay," says Denise Beveridge, director of
day services at Central Adult Daycare Services, a freestanding day program in Warwick,
R.I. "One person has been coming here for 13 years. Others are already ill and come
for a short time before they move to a skilled-nursing facility. It's a stepping stone for
the family to learn to let go a little."
Keeping Clients Active
One of the first steps to offering an adult day program is deciding which services to
offer, although, decisions of which services to provide often develop over time with input
from families and clients, explains Beveridge. Clients should also participate in a
meeting to discuss what they like and dislike.
Services
range from respite services for short periods of time to weekends and overnight options,
says Nancy Cox, deputy director of Partners in Caregiving: The Dementia Services Program,
a program created to test the notion that adult day services is a viable alternative to
skilled-nursing facilities. (The Robert Wood Foundation funds the program.) Each program
provides different ancillary services; transportation, personal care and meals are only a
few. Art therapy, hairdressing services, field trips, escorts for medical appointments,
physical therapy and counseling services should not be overlooked, says Beveridge.
According to Life After Diagnosis, a 16-page booklet printed by Partners in
Caregiving, services should include recreational activities, social services, nursing
services, rehabilitation therapy and medical services. "Services should give clients
an extra measure of support and structure so they can remain in that level of care
longer," says Rheem.
Activities should entertain, educate, arouse senses and stimulate cognitive processes.
When clients enjoy an activity, it should be scheduled regularly, says Beveridge. For
example, a trip to the library every three weeks was added to Central's schedule because
it was in such demand. Beveridge also suggests sending a survey to families to see if a
particular service would be useful. Most importantly, don't forget that nothing is set in
stone. Activities and services should be convenient and helpful to clients, but don't be
afraid to change them upon request.
Government Supervision
There aren't federal regulations for adult day programs, but state regulations and
licensure should be adhered to, says Beveridge. For example, in order for a facility to
maintain certification, Rhode Island requires nurses at every program.
Life After Diagnosis lists the requirements for adult-day-program operations: 25
states require licensure, 24 states require certification and regulations vary from state
to state. "More regulations could be great," says Beveridge. "But I also
know that increasing regulations adds more costs. We, as an industry, have to be careful
not to drive the costs up so high that people can't afford to come to daycare."
On the other hand, having no federal regulations makes it more difficult to ensure
quality, says Perry. "You want to check with your state association for licensure and
regulations, and to compare fees," she says.
Challenges to Address
While Life After Diagnosis reports that there were approximately 15 adult day
programs in 1975, 3,000 were documented by 1994. Although the industry has experienced
tremendous growth and improvements, there are three challenges that programs continue to
face:
1. Financing of services
2. Public awareness
3. Marketing
Financing of services. Running a program can be challenging
financially," says Beveridge. "You always have to watch costs." It has been
estimated that it costs approximately $200,000 to $250,000 per year to run a day program.
Everything from how many people a program will accommodate to which services will be
provided and how many hours it will be open determine costs and fees. "We look at our
true costs," continues Beveridge. "In other words, we figure out how much it
costs us to have someone in our program, and we break it down from there." She says
that because her program is not-for-profit, fees are reflected by its costs.
In order to finance a program, clients and their needs must be determined. Most
caregivers have taken a leave of absence or reduced their work hours. Caregivers need
convenient help, so what will be best for them? What hours and days will the program be
open? Which ancillary services will be provided? How much are fees? Will they cover all
operating costs? Being flexible with hours and services will prove to be a prosperous
practice all around.
Larger communities can more readily support an adult day program, says Cox, who states
that about 1 percent of a 20,000-person community (200 people) would be potential
candidates for a program's slots. A small town might not be able to support a program
based on sheer numbers, but Cox suggests expanding service populations to include
children, for example.
Grants are the main government source for adult day programs; however, many programs
accept donations, too. "There are a variety of funding sources for clients, and
Medicare is not one of them," says Rheem. "In some states Medicaid will
pay." Although private insurance and limited government aid is available, many
clients will pay for services out of pocket.
Public awareness and marketing. These go hand in hand. According to
Perry, NADSA is involved in promoting adult day services as an option for seniors and
caregivers. Partners in Caregiving reports that only 46 percent of households with a
family member 60 years or older knows about day programs; however, with marketing efforts,
the number is rising.
Each program must maintain an effective marketing regimen. "We are always present
in the community," says Beveridge, whose program works with the Alzheimer's
Association, and participates in educational programs and support groups. She adds that
all of their advertising is through word of mouth, magazine and newspaper articles, and
public speaking, which are all common marketing tools.
Partnerships
Rheem believes
adult day programs are distinct enough to stand on their own. A freestanding program can
be profitable and a wise business if it is run as such. "If used improperly,"
she says, "it becomes a feeder service for institutional care. If used properly in
conjunction with another service, it acts, as it should, as an alternative choice to that
next level of care."
Being affiliated with an assisted-living community or skilled-nursing facility can give
an adult day program a promising start. Assisted-living and skilled-nursing facilities can
offer referrals, giving the program a jump on clientele. Central Adultcare Services
maintains a lot of ties to the community, explains Beveridge. "We get referrals from
assisted-living communities and hospitals," she continues. "We all work
together. We don't feel overly competitive. We see it as giving the consumer more
choice."
Rheem says assisted living and adult day programs make a natural partnership. She says,
"If assisted living has a married couple, one of whom is declining in health,
function or ability, they can remain an intact family unit longer. This is not a
stand-alone service, though. There also has to be someone at home to provide service
during the other hours of the day."
However, one concern is that being associated with a skilled-nursing facility sometimes
brings negative images for the family or client. "Some people may not want to be
connected with a skilled-nursing facility," states Beveridge. "There is a
fear--especially with dementia patients--of being put away and not going home."
In most instances, assisted-living and skilled-nursing facilities are not in
competition with adult day programs. Most operators resolve that concern by providing
referrals. Other states, such as Rhode Island, eliminate competition by offering regional
transportation procedures, says Beveridge. Transportation is available to a person if the
person goes to a day program in the region where he lives. Although day programs can
service statewide, many people don't have transportation or can't drive to get to a
program outside of their region.
"I am not sure that any programs should be a part of another," concludes
Beveridge. "I think they all have specific personalities and joining them isn't
necessarily good."
Programs are growing in presence, but so is the demand. Marketing a program
appropriately and then providing quality care, intriguing activities, reasonable fees and
flexibility will set an adult day program on the right track. "I encourage a market
analysis and a business plan with consultants that are already successful in the
field," suggests Rheem. "This is not something to go dabbling in."
Remember that a program's main goal should be relief for the personal caregiver, and
quality care and attention for the client. "I think adult day programs are really
only now coming into their own," concludes Rheem. "I think they continue to
bridge the gap between institutional care and the home. They certainly allow the family to
remain intact in the home."
Ten Essentials for a Premier Adult Day Services Program
- Respond to the needs of customers.
- Have program hours long enough to serve working caregivers.
- Have fees that equal or exceed costs, with individualized discounts available.
- Have client transportation.
- Offer a full day of engaging activities that offer choices to clients.
- Be linked to other community services.
- Have a financial plan with a variety of reimbursement and fund-raising sources.
- Know how to use marketing principles.
- Have ongoing training for staff and support services for caregivers.
- Have a working board of directors.
Reprinted from Respite Report, Winter 1994, with permission from Partners in
Caregiving: The Dementia Services Program.
More Information About Adult Day Services
Partners in Caregiving
The Bowman Gray School of Medicine of Wake Forest University
Medical Program Boulevard
Winston-Salem, NC 27157-1087
(910) 716-4941
National Institute on Adult Daycare
The National Council on the Aging Inc.
409 Third St., SW
Washington, DC 20024
(202) 479-6682
National Association of Area Agencies on Aging
1112 16th St., NW, Suite 100
Washington, DC 20036
(202) 296-8130
National Alzheimer's Association
919 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 1000
Chicago, IL 60611-1676
(800) 272-3900
|